JohnH wrote:I have a masculine looking face and a very deep voice. Even if I wore a dress with heels and makeup, along with a feminine haircut and my feminine body shape (breasts and hips) people would have no problem determining I am male.
But how about from a distance and before they've had a chance to hear you? That "first impression" may happen from quite a distance.
I say there are many more men that go all the way with HRT (hormone replacement therapy) and SRS (sexual reassignment surgery) to become women than for women to become men.
I suspect that this is because there is still a substantial gap when it comes to status equality between men and women. This is why it's OK to be perceived as "gaining status" (as is the case with women dressing as men) and why it's NOT OK to "lose status" (the other way 'round). Until that inequality is addressed we'll continue to have this conundrum. Once men and women are perceived societally as equals this issue will go away, and I will be among the very first to make sure that it gets hit in the backside by the closing door! However, I do not see that happening any time soon as we plumb our way into a new Dark Age.
Sinned wrote:On this forum we talk about liking various things normally associated with females - nail varnish, heels and so on yet talk about not wanting to look like women. To continue this theme I have concluded that it's not the individual things but the number of them in combination.
In this case, I believe it's down to two things: (1) the individual's "tipping-point" and (2) society's "tipping-point" regarding what's "acceptable" or not. Each of us have our own, and society in one's locale likely has another; balancing those is an art. Personally, I tend to take my own tipping-point as the datum and not get too close to it; if I find that I am disturbed by the visage in the mirror (or, more accurately, a photograph; pictures are less "forgiving" than the mirror) or do not recognise myself therein, I will not cultivate that look or style in public.
It's worth noting that I pretty much cannot be "mistaken for a woman" (I'd make a really nad one anyway) as I'm big (in the 99th percentile for height in the USA and one could well add a nine or two following the decimal for women), sport facial hair, and, even though I have a waist-length ponytail (which I sometimes wear "down"), other cues mark me as unmistakably male. However, even I have managed to push things to the point where I got somewhat "wigged out" by the "man in the mirror" -- and those are looks that I will not use in public (and usually do not repeat even in private). So it's a matter of degree.
ChrisM came up with the rather intuitive "Rule of One" (i.e. "One item of 'feminine' apparel at a time") which works, although with the length of my hair I seem to find myself routinely violating it as I like tying it back with various barettes, bows, and whatnot. Go figure.